Two navy shirts, two different fits
The Big Oxford in Navy and the Knit Polo in Vintage Blue Boxweave share a color family, but they are built for different kinds of wear. The Big Oxford is cut with a wide chest and shoulders and looser sleeves, while the Knit Polo is a buttonless knit with an open collar. Your choice comes down to whether you want an oversized woven shirt or a softer knit that sits closer to the body.
This comparison sticks to what the product records confirm. Where a detail is not supplied, such as exact care instructions or stretch recovery rates, I will say so rather than guess.
Fit and sizing evidence
- Big Oxford ~ Navy: The Big Oxford is cut with a wide chest and shoulders, coupled with looser sleeves. The generous proportions are matched with a carefully considered body and sleeve length so the shirt maintains its oversized feeling without appearing too big. This tells you the Big Oxford is intentionally oversized but not sloppy. If you want a relaxed, roomy shirt, this is the one.

Big Oxford ~ Navy - Big Oxford ~ Navy: Model is 5'7" / 150lbs and wears a size Small. A reference point for smaller frames. If you are around this height and weight, Small is the brand's shown fit.
- Knit Polo ~ Vintage Blue Boxweave: Measurements are taken as the sweater is laid flat with no stretch. As is the case with all sweaters, ours will stretch and recover, so please factor this in when choosing a size. The Knit Polo's fit is not fixed. It will give with wear and return when washed or rested, so choose a size that works with that movement.

Knit Polo ~ Vintage Blue Boxweave - Knit Polo ~ Vintage Blue Boxweave: Generally, we find that you can take the same size in this sweater that you do in our other tops. A simple starting point if you already own 3sixteen tops. The Knit Polo is designed to match your usual size.
- Knit Polo ~ Vintage Blue Boxweave: Model is 6'3" / 175lbs and wears a size Medium. A reference for taller, leaner frames. If you are around this build, Medium is the shown fit.
Which fit suits your frame and preference
If you like a shirt that feels roomy through the chest and sleeves, the Big Oxford's oversized cut is the draw. It is designed to look deliberately generous without swallowing you. The Knit Polo, by contrast, is a sweater knit: it follows the body more closely and relies on the natural stretch and recovery of the pima cotton. If you prefer a cleaner, closer line, the polo is the better match.
Neither fit is "better" in the abstract. The question is whether you want the structured volume of an oxford or the soft, adaptive fit of a knit.
Fabric and construction details
- Big Oxford ~ Navy: 100% cotton, garment dyed for a perfectly lived-in color. Mother of pearl buttons. Made in Portugal. Garment dyeing gives the navy a softer, worn-in look from the start. The mother of pearl buttons add a traditional detail.
- Knit Polo ~ Vintage Blue Boxweave: 100% Pima Cotton yarn, knit by a partner factory in Peru. The yarn is irregularly dyed for a vintage, heathered effect. Pima cotton is known for a soft hand. The irregular dye creates a heathered look, so the Vintage Blue color is not flat or uniform.
- Knit Polo ~ Vintage Blue Boxweave: Buttonless, continuous placket and open collar that sits nicely on the chest. This gives the polo a relaxed, unfussy neckline that works well without a tie or under a jacket.
Layering and outfit ideas
The Big Oxford's roomy cut makes it an easy layer over a T-shirt or under a sweater. Its oversized shape means you can wear it open over a tee without it feeling tight. The Knit Polo, with its open collar and buttonless placket, works well on its own or under a jacket. Because it is a knit, it sits closer to the body, so layering a heavy piece over it may feel restrictive.
For a casual navy shirt look, the Big Oxford pairs naturally with jeans or chinos. The Knit Polo's heathered Vintage Blue finish gives it a slightly more textured, vintage feel that works with denim or tailored trousers. Neither product record specifies exact outfit combinations, so treat these as starting points rather than rules.
Side-by-side: which navy shirt fits your use
- Big Oxford in Navy: Choose this if you want an intentionally oversized woven shirt with a lived-in garment-dyed color. It suits casual layering and a relaxed silhouette. The model is 5'7" / 150lbs in a Small, so size down if you want a closer fit.
- Knit Polo in Vintage Blue Boxweave: Choose this if you prefer a soft knit that follows the body and has a heathered, vintage look. It works well on its own or under a jacket. Take your usual size in 3sixteen tops, and factor in that the sweater will stretch and recover with wear.
What the records do not settle
The product records do not provide specific care instructions for either shirt. For the Knit Polo, we know the measurements are taken flat with no stretch, but the record does not specify how much the sweater will stretch or how to wash it. For the Big Oxford, the record confirms garment dyeing but not whether the color will fade further with washing. If care details matter to you, check the garment's labels when it arrives or contact the store for guidance.
Neither record gives exact sleeve lengths or body measurements beyond the model references. Use the model sizing as a rough guide, but your best fit will come from trying the shirt or comparing to a shirt you already own.


